Published by Jenny on 25 Feb 2009
Social networking really bad for your health?
A story doing the rounds at the moment is the news that social networks are bad for our health.
As the BBC says: “Britons could be jeopardising their health as they spend more time in virtual worlds than the real one, according to the psychologist Dr Aric Sigman.”
This story will “have legs” (as they say) – not only is it about the latest geek / media topic (social media), but it is also science (a subject that it can be difficult to find stories with mass appeal about).
The story is given credibility by Dr Sigman’s impressive credentials. According to his own website, he is “a Fellow of the Royal Society of Medicine, an Associate Fellow of the British Psychological Society, Member of the Institute of Biology” etc.
To summarise the health issue exposed, according to the journal Biologist, lonely people are more susceptible to strokes, high blood pressure, dementia and are more likely to die early.
This has been extrapolated into a warning that people who depend on virtual networks for their social contact are at risk of the same health problems.
So far so reasonable and you can’t blame Dr Sigman for the subs creating scary headlines like: “Virtual worlds are damaging our children’s health”.
The simple, practical warning that spending too much time alone can lead to isolation and, in turn, to poor health is now lost in a big old moral panic.
Hmmm, now here comes the science bit…well not really. I did a quick Google search for Dr Aric Sigman and in the first page of results there were some familiar stories.
19th Feb 2007: The 15 ways in which too much TV wrecks your child’s health (The Mail)
7th Aug 2008: How seeing movies like Batman can turn our children violent (Also The Mail)
Also 19th Feb 2007: Turn off TV girls or risk early puberty (The Times)
Oct 1st 2005 : How TV is (quite literally) killing us ( Whale)
It’s clear that Dr Sigman is a passionate campaigner for his subject, but the re-spinning of this original story to piggyback the wave of stories on social networking ultimately weakens the scientific statement.
This is not a bashing of Dr Signman! I would like to point out that, we are undoubtedly in agreement on the following points.
Too much TV is bad!
Watching violent TV / films at an early age is bad!
ONLY having virtual friends is bad!
However, virtual networks do offer an outlet to create friendships for people who have difficulties dealing with “real life” social situations – and therefore, they must be a good thing – providing the attendant health benefits.
What do you think about this and bad science stories in general?
Read Oscar Carreras on the negative reputation campaign against social media




Lingerie brand Agent Provocateur has launched an online social media campaign to promote its Hello Agent Provocateur blog using Facebook, Flickr and Twitter.